Showing posts with label trials. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trials. Show all posts

Saturday

IP-Centrex Field Trials

IP-Centrex Field Trials
The electronic government department of the State of Wisconsin conducted a field trial of IP-Centrex, based on Lucent's iMerge product, in conjunction with SBC Communications, in late 2001. The state is a very large Centrex customer, with well over 60,000 lines in state offices, universities, and local agencies, such as county and city governments.

The Centrex features were derived from a 5ESS CO switch in Lisle, Illinois, and carried 145 miles over a T1 link to the state's offices in Madison, using the configuration shown in Figure 1. The equipment in Lisle was shared with the much larger IP-Centrex pilot test at Lucent's own campus in Naperville, Illinois (which is described below).


Figure 14: IP-Centrex trial network.


This project in Madison lasted for 90 days and involved only 11 users, based on a preexisting 10/100 Mbps LAN, which has approximately 100 users on each Ethernet switch. Unidata IW200 IP phone sets were used for this trial. These telephones employ the H.323 protocol, with a G.711 codec, echo cancellation, an internal hub, and local ac power supply.

The trial's coordinator concluded that the successes of this project were that all the features of Centrex, including 911 calls and voice mail, continued to work, there was full integration into the State's five-digit dialing scheme, and there were no apparent issues with the LAN.

A number of problems were identified, such as intermittent voice clipping and fading, frequent echoing and excessive background noise in the sets, infrequently dropped calls, and two complete service outages. Users also complained about a slight delay in obtaining dialtone and poor telephone set ergonomics.

The conclusions from this small trial were that home-based workers and "road-warriors" are most likely to benefit from IP-Centrex, while no applications have yet been written for the IP phones.

SBC Communications deployed an ambitious trial of IP-Centrex, jointly with Lucent, at that company's new technology center at Naperville, Illinois, in the spring of 2001. This live network trial served more than 1,600 product development, design, and test personnel through an iMerge Centrex Feature Gateway linked to the 5ESS central office system, which also provides digital Centrex service to 10,000 employees on the same industrial campus.

A 2-month trial of IP-Centrex was conducted in the spring of 2002 at the University of Toronto (UTO), in partnership with Bell Canada and Nortel Networks. The university rents about 12,000 Centrex lines for its 200 buildings, spread over four campuses, with single wire center service for each campus. All intercampus calling is done over the PSTN, with 10-digit dialing within and between two area codes, as all the sites are in one extended local calling area. UTO has been a digital Centrex customer since 1986 and currently has a 5-year contract, at $14.35 per month per line.

For the last 5 years the university has subscribed to the Station Configuration Management service, which allows a customer's own telecom personnel to implement some moves, additions, or change orders in real time. However, the more complex change requests need the participation of Bell's technicians in the CO, where their turnaround time for work on one to five sets is up to 1 week. It turns out that approximately 75% of orders need at least some action by the telco, so the telecommunications manager sends the whole request to Bell, since the university would not save any money by doing part of the job and splitting responsibility for a work order increases the possibility of errors. In other words, UTO's telecom analysts can only do about 25% of the MAC requests that are received from their users in the legacy Centrex environment.

UTO owns three Avaya/Octel voice mail systems, with one unit being installed at each of its main campuses, and has a total of 6,800 voice mailboxes. Six thousand mailboxes are used for the large downtown campus, while the Aerospace Studies Institute, in northern Toronto, rents 100 voice mailboxes from the telco's call manager service. There are some 80 bulletin board services also based on the Avaya systems, which vary greatly in size and usage.

A three-position switchboard continues to be ample to handle calls through the main listed number, which is first answered by a recorded announcement, with option 1 going to the operator and option 2 to the main menu.

Bell Canada has provided a stable, dedicated team of support people to UTO, and this has led to a QoS for legacy Centrex that cannot be beaten.

Thirty users, located in several buildings on the downtown Toronto campus, participated in the IP-Centrex trial. The service was delivered over a T1 link from the same DMS-100 system that provides legacy Centrex. These users included administrators, academics, and IT personnel. Each participant had a Nortel i2004 phone plus a SIP Client package in the desktop PC. These people have found it hard to adapt to the softphone and much prefer to use the IP telephone set. Voice quality over IP-Centrex was very good when calling within the trial group or to other Centrex phones in the university. The most significant quality difference was on some calls with cell phones, when "clipping" sometimes occurred. Compared with legacy Centrex, there was also some loss of quality on conference calls; the audio degraded as more participants were added.

Responsibility for data networks at UTO is split between the central IT department, which looks after the optical fiber backbone between buildings, and the department responsible for a specific building, which controls the LANs inside that building. All LANs deliver switched Fast Ethernet to each desktop, but the quality of local network management differs widely.

Within this university environment there is not much call for the networked applications that are offered by IP-Centrex. No one is asking for UM and there are no requirements for CRM. The ability to set up a short-term, virtual call center may be helpful for a few class projects and the potential easily to adjust the number of lines to meet seasonal demand in student residences may have some value.

The real interest in this case is how IP-Centrex will be tariffed. Because the switching is being done in customer-owned equipment, the rates should be lower than with legacy Centrex, but there is not yet any information available as to how much less the costs will actually be. At the very least, there is hope that the implementation of IP-Centrex may allow the university to increase its share of in-house MACs from one-quarter to three-quarters of the total.

Monday

IP-Centrex—Prospects and Pilot Trials

IP-Centrex—Prospects and Pilot Trials
Because relatively few organizations have implemented IP-Centrex on a commercial basis and many telecom service providers work in a highly competitive environment, it has been a challenge to obtain information about appropriate case studies. The situation of a large Centrex customer, which participated in a limited IP-Centrex technology trial, is then described in some detail. Finally, we include descriptions of several IP-Centrex trials for which some information has been made available.

IP-Centrex Prospects

A municipal government that serves a city of over 250,000 people has 900 full-time employees supported by Centrex in 70 locations, some of which are indicated in the map in Figure 1. The city's Works Department has a fairly modern 120-station PBX, rather than using Centrex, because it is located outside the serving area of the main Centrex-providing CO. The municipality's Centrex service contract is approaching the end of its 10-year term, during which it has provided each line at an attractive 50% discount off the current rate. A new Centrex contract would look expensive to the city because of structural changes in the tariff within recent years. The CIO of this city, therefore, faces a dilemma regarding the annual telephone service bill of $300,000, with the choice of moving to a network of conventional PBX systems, investing in anew IP-PBX infrastructure, or hoping to use IP-Centrex as being suited to an organization with many small offices. There is a serious drawback with each alternative as the system vendors wind down the development of circuit-switched PBXs; the technology of IP-PBXs seems not yet to be settled and the local ILEC cannot offer a schedule for IP-Centrex availability.


Figure 1: Municipal locations.


The city owns an optical fiber network that can be linked into locations housing 90% of its personnel. This fiber is installed in ducts that were primarily used for the copper cables linking traffic lights to the traffic control computer center.

Probably the best solution is to negotiate a 1-year extension to the present Centrex contract and hope that the options become more clearly defined meanwhile.

A newly organized health care corporation needs to integrate the services of four hospitals, located as on the map in Figure 2. The hospitals and associated clinics employ about 1,500 phones and 50 fax machines. One-third of the phones are single-line, analog sets and are in patients' rooms. The largest hospital in this group, with about 50% of the lines, has a seriously out-of-date PBX and overloaded voice mail/autoattendant subsystem. A major objective is to present a single image to the public served by the health care corporation, as each site will concentrate on selected specializations to achieve optimum economies of scale.


Figure 2: Healthcare network integrates four hospitals.


The corporation's board also intends to implement video communications extensively, within a short time frame, to minimize travel time and expenses, for both professional staff and patients. IP-compatible video-conferencing units from several well-established vendors are now available at very competitive prices.

Because this health care organization is in a small, rural town, beyond commuting distance from a large city, it has great difficulty in recruiting and retaining well-trained telecom professionals. Additionally, this market area is not yet attractive to competitive broadband network providers. A deployment strategy that uses IP-Centrex at the largest hospital and integrates three existing small-to-medium PBXs into the corporate network with IP trunk gateway cards is probably the best solution. TI links leased from the telco will serve sites W and E, while the smaller hospital at N will have frame-relay data service at a fractional TI bit rate.

A solo consultant has been a small Centrex customer for 10 years, working from his home office. The positive side of small Centrex is that lots of features (including calling line ID and three-party conference calling) are bundled into the service with no extra costs, at a rental not much above that for a basic business line. The negatives are that there have been no service improvements for a decade, the service is not well marketed, and no one at the local telco's office is willing to talk about small Centrex. The service provider has, obviously, not tried to mine its customer database or to get new services out to these small businesses. Additionally, this customer has not received one sales pitch from any Centrex reseller, in the last 10 years, to sell competitive services. Another concern is that the electronic business set (EBS), which has digital signaling, uses local ac power and is not on during a power failure.

To provide for good service quality, this small office requires two Centrex lines and needs three "PSTN accesses" so that two calls can be handled simultaneously and a third call can be diverted to voice mail. One of the two physical Centrex lines is defined as analog, to serve a fax machine, and that line is also used for ADSL, providing high-speed Internet access. The total monthly rental for two Centrex lines and three network accesses (not including the ADSL service) is about $80.

Since there are no restrictions on access to competitive services, the consultant rents unified messaging from Sprint (at approximately $10 monthly for 200 minutes of storage), because a single voice mailbox is provided for calls to the Centrex wireline phones and to a cell phone. The ILEC, which provides the small Centrex, has configured its own voice mail service in a way that does not allow call forwarding from any number other than the Centrex line. This customer has installed a total of six outlets in his house, so that he can move phones, fax, or modem around without paying any relocation fees.

For small and home office (SOHO) users, the prospects with IP-Centrex are as follows:

- All services will use one DSL access line.

- Some Computer Telephony Integration (CTI) functionality, such as the availability of an on-line dialing list, will be available.

- Programmable IP telephones that receive DC power over the wires from the CO will be sold at reasonable prices.

- Integrated UM service will be accessible from a cell phone, or other mobile devices, in most locations, if served by a digital radio network
Related Posts with Thumbnails

Link Exchange